Divider
Content Divider

Cay Condo Properties for Sale in Key Colony, FL

Researching this community? View previous sales at Cay Condo. Let one our Keys area experts help you out.

Total Listings 4
Order By:

$459,000
Key Colony
Cay Condo - MM: 53.50
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,234 SqFt Days Listed: 137
-8.02% ($40,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 28 Days Ago
Condo - Contingent - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Discover the charm of oceanfront living at an exceptional value in The Cay Condos, located in the heart of Key Colony Beach. Known for its small-town feel and pristine beaches, this walkable, bikeable island offers a host of amenities, including a par-3 golf course, marina, tennis and pickleball courts, and a variety of local restaurants. This 2-bedroom, 2-bath unit provides a welcoming retreat within a vibrant beachfront community. Residents enjoy a picturesque oceanfront courtyard with a pool, a beachfront tiki hut, a private sandy beach, party room and a community deck perfect for savoring breathtaking sunsets. With first-level living for easy accessibility and a calendar full of community events, this is your chance to embrace the best of Florida Keys living at an affordable price.

$599,000
Key Colony
Cay Condo - MM: 53.50
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,234 SqFt Days Listed: 13
Condo - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Just about halfway between Key Largo and Key West, youll find a lovely condo association with a gorgeous beach and inviting turquoise waters, perfect for your next getaway! This charming ground-level condo features 2 cozy bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, offering a fantastic location thats close enough to the fun of Key West and Key Largo, yet tranquil enough to relax and unwind.Youll love how easy it is to explore everything the area has to offer! Whether its dining at local restaurants, indulging in some shopping, or setting off on fishing and diving adventures, all your favorite activities are just a short bike ride or a pleasant stroll away. Dont forget to check out Sunset Park while youre at it!Unit 203A has been part of the rental pool and can be rented for a minimum of 14 days, making it a wonderful investment opportunity. Plus, it comes fully furnished and turnkey--just bring your suitcase and enjoy!

$649,000
Key Colony
Cay Condo - MM: 53.50
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,343 SqFt Days Listed: 19
Condo - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Escape to paradise with this spacious townhouse-style condo offering stunning beach and ocean views in the heart of Key Colony Beach, Florida Keys. Let the sights and sounds of the sea sweep you into the relaxed rhythm of island life.With over 1,300 square feet of living space, theres plenty of room for you, your family, and friends to entertain, unwind, and create unforgettable memories. Whether youre looking for a retirement oasis, weekend escape, or investment property, this beachside gem has it all for you .NEW Photos - Virtual Tour and Floor Plan are now available. Experience the full charm of this Florida Keys retreat!

$650,000
Key Colony
Cay Condo - MM: 53.50
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,343 SqFt Days Listed: 210
-6.74% ($47,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 14 Days Ago
Condo - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

OCEAN VIEWS welcome you as you step into this updated condo and 14 day or longer rentals are allowed. You are immediately greeted by breathtaking views of the blue water and the white sand beach. The nicely renovated kitchen has tons of cabinets and counter tops for the chef in the family to prepare feasts to enjoy oceanside. The newly updated primary bath is lovely with walk-in shower and custom finishes . You will treasure the memories made while sipping coffee or enjoying an adult beverage on the balcony while taking in the tropical landscaping and mesmerizing blue water views. Amenities include heated, decked pool, HUGE beachfront tiki, community deck for sunsets, happy hour and grilling and gorgeous, private beach. Your Island retreat is waiting here on Key Colony Beach, where you can walk or bike the entire city to marina, restaurants, pickle ball, golf, tennis, bocce ball, horse shoes, basket ball, post office and Sunset Park.

More Info
Most Recent Sales - (4) - Cay Condo as of 2025-04-23
Sale Date Address Sale Price $/SF List Price Sq. Ft. Type Bd/Ba Days Listed
03-03-2025 601 Ocean 112D $625,000 $465 $699,000 1,344 Condo 2/2 149
11-08-2024 601 Ocean 311D $547,000 $407 $549,000 1,343 Condo 2/2 114
12-15-2023 601 Ocean 302B $625,000 $506 $640,000 1,234 Condo 2/2 129
05-19-2023 601 Ocean 205C $640,000 $433 $675,000 1,475 Condo 2/2 163
Thinking about selling your Cay Condo home?

Get a free no obligation home value report and know your home's value, even if you are just curious. If you decide to sell or are considering it, our company specializes in selling homes in your community and we can provide you with the guidance on the process that will generate the most return on your investment. Inquire below for a free comparative market analysis of your property. All communication is private and no obligation.

Provide us with some quick details so we can setup a free no obligation and confidential phone call.

More Info


Enter
dsfj
The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 04-23-2025.
Back To TopMore Info
Terms / Privacy / Accessibility ADA